Request 532820: Submit libqt5-qtspeech

Overview

Request 532820 accepted

No description set

Created by Vogtinator over 6 years ago
In state accepted

Submit libqt5-qtspeech

Comments for request 532820 5

Jan Engelhardt (jengelh) - over 6 years ago

reviewer

@dimstar is very wary of .changes entries like that. You only provided a URL, that's not ok by our guidelines.

It's reasonably easy to bring across the general overview of the submission:

- Update to bugfix release 5.9.2
  * some 300 bug fixes
  * details at http://qtqtqtqtqt...

that should do it.

Fabian Vogt (Vogtinator) - over 6 years ago

author source maintainer

Would https://code.qt.io/cgit/qt/qtbase.git/tree/dist/changes-5.9.2/?h=v5.9.2 be a better link?

Jan Engelhardt (jengelh) - over 6 years ago

reviewer

It is not about the hyperlink or its presence, it is about the absence of non-links.

Fabian Vogt (Vogtinator) - over 6 years ago

author source maintainer

There's nothing meaningful we can add there, except literally "Some bugs fixed, maybe some added" though. A list of all referenced bugs might be doable, but that doesn't really represent valuable information either.

Jan Engelhardt (jengelh) - over 6 years ago

reviewer

Some bugs fixed, maybe some added

Now they're adding bugs? As a user, I'd definitely want to know ;-)

Anyhow, looking at the different possibilities now explored here, note how each of these ways of wording convey a different urgency to the user:

Update to 5.9.2, 'http://now.fuck/off'
Update to bugfix release 5.9.2; ~300 small bugs fixed
Update to bugfix release 5.42.42; 1 big bug that ate your data fixed
Update to 5.50.50, maybe some bugs added

I think the last three are all better than the first in the list.

Request History

Vogtinator created request over 6 years ago

factory-auto added opensuse-review-team as a reviewer over 6 years ago

Please review sources

factory-auto added repo-checker as a reviewer over 6 years ago

Please review build success

factory-auto accepted review over 6 years ago

Check script succeeded

Output of check script (non-fatal):
Unknown license 'LGPL-2.1-with-Qt-Company-Qt-exception-1.1'
Unknown license 'LGPL-3.0-with-Qt-Company-Qt-exception-1.1'
Unknown license 'LGPL-2.1-with-Qt-Company-Qt-exception-1.1'
Unknown license 'LGPL-3.0-with-Qt-Company-Qt-exception-1.1'