File utils-relax-mount-rules.diff of Package apparmor

Overview Repositories Revisions Requests Users Attributes Meta

File utils-relax-mount-rules.diff of Package apparmor (Revision c810bd9816fe6c535130090b0e7835b2)

Currently displaying revision c810bd9816fe6c535130090b0e7835b2 , Show latest

commit eee50538da9a240bc151f26c6cff309808d33590
Author: Georgia Garcia <georgia.garcia@canonical.com>
Date:   Wed May 8 12:58:42 2024 +0000

Merge MountRule: Relaxing constraints on fstype and completing AARE support
    
     - Before this commit, fstype had to match a known fs. However, having and maintaining the exhaustive list of fstypes proved challenging (see !1195 and !1176). Therefore, we add support for any filesystem name.
     - Completing AARE support for fstype (brace expressions like ext{3,4} are now supported).
    
    MR: https://gitlab.com/apparmor/apparmor/-/merge_requests/1198
    Approved-by: Christian Boltz <apparmor@cboltz.de>
    Merged-by: Christian Boltz <apparmor@cboltz.de>
    
    
    (cherry picked from commit baa8b67248f3467cde40683600d7a945b05f9a3b)
    
    dad5ee28 MountRule: Relaxing constraints on fstype and completing AARE support
    
    Co-authored-by: Christian Boltz <apparmor@cboltz.de>

diff --git a/utils/apparmor/rule/mount.py b/utils/apparmor/rule/mount.py
index f62c08e4b..abfa2b75e 100644
--- a/utils/apparmor/rule/mount.py
+++ b/utils/apparmor/rule/mount.py
@@ -23,19 +23,7 @@ from apparmor.translations import init_translation
 
 _ = init_translation()
 
-# TODO :
-#   - match correctly AARE on every field
-#   - Find the actual list of supported filesystems. This one comes from /proc/filesystems. We also blindly accept fuse.*
-#   - Support path that begin by { (e.g. {,/usr}/lib/...) This syntax is not a valid AARE but is used by usr.lib.snapd.snap-confine.real in Ubuntu and will currently raise an error in genprof if these lines are not modified.
-#   - Apparmor remount logs are displayed as mount (with remount flag). Profiles generated with aa-genprof are therefore mount rules. It could be interesting to make them remount rules.
-
-valid_fs = [
-    'sysfs', 'tmpfs', 'bdevfs', 'procfs', 'cgroup', 'cgroup2', 'cpuset', 'devtmpfs', 'configfs', 'debugfs', 'tracefs',
-    'securityfs', 'sockfs', 'bpf', 'npipefs', 'ramfs', 'hugetlbfs', 'devpts', 'ext3', 'ext2', 'ext4', 'squashfs',
-    'vfat', 'ecryptfs', 'fuseblk', 'fuse', 'fusectl', 'efivarfs', 'mqueue', 'store', 'autofs', 'binfmt_misc', 'overlay',
-    'none', 'bdev', 'proc', 'pipefs', 'pstore', 'btrfs', 'xfs', '9p', 'resctrl', 'zfs', 'iso9660', 'udf', 'ntfs3',
-    'nfs', 'cifs', 'overlayfs', 'aufs', 'rpc_pipefs', 'msdos', 'nfs4',
-]
+# TODO : Apparmor remount logs are displayed as mount (with remount flag). Profiles generated with aa-genprof are therefore mount rules. It could be interesting to make them remount rules.
 
 flags_keywords = [
     # keep in sync with parser/mount.cc mnt_opts_table!
@@ -48,7 +36,6 @@ flags_keywords = [
     '([A-Za-z0-9])',
 ]
 join_valid_flags = '|'.join(flags_keywords)
-join_valid_fs = '|'.join(valid_fs)
 
 sep = r'\s*[\s,]\s*'
 
@@ -106,27 +93,18 @@ class MountRule(BaseRule):
 
         self.operation = operation
 
-        self.fstype, self.all_fstype, unknown_items = check_and_split_list(fstype[1] if fstype != self.ALL else fstype, valid_fs, self.ALL, type(self).__name__, 'fstype')
-
-        if unknown_items:
-            for it in unknown_items:
-
-                # Several filesystems use fuse internally and are referred as fuse.<software_name> (e.g. fuse.jmtpfs, fuse.s3fs, fuse.obexfs).
-                # Since this list seems to evolve too fast for a fixed list to work in practice, we just accept fuse.*
-                # See https://github.com/libfuse/libfuse/wiki/Filesystems and, https://doc.ubuntu-fr.org/fuse
-                if it.startswith('fuse.') and len(it) > 5:
-                    continue
-
-                it = AARE(it, is_path=False)
-                found = False
-                for fs in valid_fs:
-                    if self._is_covered_aare(it, self.all_fstype, AARE(fs, False), self.all_fstype, 'fstype'):
-                        found = True
-                        break
-                if not found:
-                    raise AppArmorException(_('Passed unknown fstype keyword to %s: %s') % (type(self).__name__, ' '.join(unknown_items)))
-
-        self.is_fstype_equal = fstype[0] if not self.all_fstype else None
+        if fstype == self.ALL or fstype[1] == self.ALL:
+            self.all_fstype = True
+            self.fstype = None
+            self.is_fstype_equal = None
+        else:
+            self.all_fstype = False
+            for it in fstype[1]:
+                l, unused = parse_aare(it, 0, 'fstype')
+                if l != len(it):
+                    raise AppArmorException(f'Invalid aare : {it}')
+            self.fstype = fstype[1]
+            self.is_fstype_equal = fstype[0]
 
         self.options, self.all_options, unknown_items = check_and_split_list(options[1] if options != self.ALL else options, flags_keywords, self.ALL, type(self).__name__, 'options')
         if unknown_items:
@@ -173,7 +151,7 @@ class MountRule(BaseRule):
 
             if r['fstype'] is not None:
                 is_fstype_equal = r['fstype_equals_or_in']
-                fstype = strip_parenthesis(r['fstype']).replace(',', ' ').split()
+                fstype = parse_aare_list(strip_parenthesis(r['fstype']), 'fstype')
             else:
                 is_fstype_equal = None
                 fstype = cls.ALL
@@ -316,6 +294,38 @@ class MountRuleset(BaseRuleset):
     '''Class to handle and store a collection of Mount rules'''
 
 
+
+def parse_aare(s, offset, param):
+    parsed = ''
+    brace_count = 0
+    for i, c in enumerate(s[offset:], start=offset):
+        if c in [' ', ',', '\t'] and brace_count == 0:
+            break
+        parsed += c
+        if c == '{':
+            brace_count += 1
+        elif c == '}':
+            brace_count -= 1
+            if brace_count < 0:
+                raise AppArmorException(f"Unmatched closing brace in {param}: {s[offset:]}")
+        offset = i
+
+    if brace_count != 0:
+        raise AppArmorException(f"Unmatched opening brace in {param}: {s[offset:]}")
+
+    return offset + 1, parsed
+
+
+def parse_aare_list(s, param):
+    res = []
+    offset = 0
+    while offset <= len(s):
+        offset, part = parse_aare(s, offset, param)
+        if part.translate(' ,\t') != '':
+            res.append(part)
+    return res
+
+
 def wrap_in_with_spaces(value):
     ''' wrap 'in' keyword in spaces, and leave everything else unchanged '''
 
diff --git a/utils/test/test-mount.py b/utils/test/test-mount.py
index e37c287c7..7f88ff7db 100644
--- a/utils/test/test-mount.py
+++ b/utils/test/test-mount.py
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ from common_test import AATest, setup_all_loops
 from apparmor.common import AppArmorException, AppArmorBug
 from apparmor.translations import init_translation
 
-from apparmor.rule.mount import MountRule, valid_fs
+from apparmor.rule.mount import MountRule
 
 _ = init_translation()
 
@@ -31,34 +31,34 @@ class MountTestParse(AATest):
         #                   Rule                                                     Operation   Filesystem                Options                  Source          Destination     Audit  Deny   Allow  Comment
         ('mount -> **,',                                                    MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  '**',           False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount options=(rw, shared) -> **,',                               MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            ('=', ('rw', 'shared')), MountRule.ALL,  '**',           False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=bpf options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',                MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('bpf')),           ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=fuse.obex* options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('fuse.obex*')),    ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=fuse.* options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',             MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('fuse.*')),        ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=bpf options=(rw) random_label -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',     MountRule('mount',   ('=', ("bpf")),           ('=', ('rw')),           'random_label', '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=bpf options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',                MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['bpf']),           ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=fuse.obex* options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['fuse.obex*']),    ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=fuse.* options=rw bpf -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',             MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['fuse.*']),        ('=', ('rw')),           'bpf',          '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=bpf options=(rw) random_label -> /sys/fs/bpf/,',     MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['bpf']),           ('=', ('rw')),           'random_label', '/sys/fs/bpf/', False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount,',                                                          MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4),',                                      MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4),',                                      MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount bpf,',                                                      MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           'bpf',          MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount none,',                                                     MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           'none',         MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro),',                         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  ('=', ('ro')),           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro),',                         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  ('=', ('ro')),           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount @{mntpnt},',                                                MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           '@{mntpnt}',    MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('mount /a,',                                                       MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           '/a',           MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) /a -> /b,',                             MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  MountRule.ALL,           '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b,',         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt',    MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options in (ro, rbind) /a -> /b,',      MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  ('in', ('ro', 'rbind')), '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('mount fstype in (ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt', MountRule('mount',   ('in', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
-        ('mount fstype in (ext3, ext4) option in (ro, rbind) /a, #cmt',     MountRule('mount',   ('in', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('in', ('ro', 'rbind')), '/a',           MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
-        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) option=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt',     MountRule('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) /a -> /b,',                             MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  MountRule.ALL,           '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b,',         MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt',    MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
+        ('mount fstype=({ext3,ext4}) options in (ro, rbind) /a -> /b,',     MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['{ext3,ext4}']),   ('in', ('ro', 'rbind')), '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('mount fstype in (ext3, ext4) options=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt', MountRule('mount',   ('in', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
+        ('mount fstype in (ext3, ext4) option in (ro, rbind) /a, #cmt',     MountRule('mount',   ('in', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('in', ('ro', 'rbind')), '/a',           MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
+        ('mount fstype=(ext3, ext4) option=(ro, rbind) /a -> /b, #cmt',     MountRule('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),  ('=', ('ro', 'rbind')),  '/a',           '/b',           False, False, False, ' #cmt')),
         ('mount options=(rw, rbind) {,/usr}/lib{,32,64,x32}/modules/ -> /tmp/snap.rootfs_*{,/usr}/lib/modules/,',
                                                                             MountRule('mount',   MountRule.ALL,            ('=', ('rw', 'rbind')),  '{,/usr}/lib{,32,64,x32}/modules/',
                                                                                                                                                                    '/tmp/snap.rootfs_*{,/usr}/lib/modules/',
                                                                                                                                                                                     False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('umount,',                                                         MountRule('umount',  MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('umount fstype=ext3,',                                             MountRule('umount',  ('=', ('ext3')),          MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('umount fstype=ext3,',                                             MountRule('umount',  ('=', ['ext3']),          MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('umount /a,',                                                      MountRule('umount',  MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  '/a',           False, False, False, ''     )),
 
         ('remount,',                                                        MountRule('remount', MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
-        ('remount fstype=ext4,',                                            MountRule('remount', ('=', ('ext4')),          MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
+        ('remount fstype=ext4,',                                            MountRule('remount', ('=', ['ext4']),          MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  MountRule.ALL,  False, False, False, ''     )),
         ('remount /b,',                                                     MountRule('remount', MountRule.ALL,            MountRule.ALL,           MountRule.ALL,  '/b',           False, False, False, ''     )),
     )
 
@@ -72,7 +72,6 @@ class MountTestParse(AATest):
 class MountTestParseInvalid(AATest):
     tests = (
         ('mount fstype=,',           AppArmorException),
-        ('mount fstype=(foo),',      AppArmorException),
         ('mount fstype=(),',         AppArmorException),
         ('mount options=(),',        AppArmorException),
         ('mount option=(invalid),',  AppArmorException),
@@ -90,7 +89,7 @@ class MountTestParseInvalid(AATest):
 
     def test_diff_non_mountrule(self):
         exp = namedtuple('exp', ('audit', 'deny'))
-        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', 'ext4'), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext4']), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
         with self.assertRaises(AppArmorBug):
             obj.is_equal(exp(False, False), False)
 
@@ -98,9 +97,25 @@ class MountTestParseInvalid(AATest):
         with self.assertRaises(AppArmorBug):
             MountRule('mount', ('ext3', 'ext4'), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)  # fstype[0] should be '=' or 'in'
 
-    def test_diff_invalid_fstype_keyword(self):
-        with self.assertRaises(AppArmorException):
-            MountRule('mount', ('=', 'invalidfs'), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)  # fstype[0] should be '=' or 'in'
+    def test_diff_invalid_fstype_aare(self):
+        tests = [
+                'mount fstype=({unclosed_regex),',
+                'mount fstype=({closed}twice}),',
+        ]
+
+        for t in tests:
+            with self.assertRaises(AppArmorException):
+                MountRule.create_instance(t)
+
+    def test_diff_invalid_fstype_aare_2(self):
+        fslists = [
+                ['invalid_{_regex'],
+                ['ext4', 'invalid_}_regex'],
+                ['ext4', '{invalid} {regex}']
+        ]
+        for fslist in fslists:
+            with self.assertRaises(AppArmorException):
+                MountRule('mount', ('=', fslist), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
 
     def test_diff_invalid_options_equals_or_in(self):
         with self.assertRaises(AppArmorBug):
@@ -111,7 +126,7 @@ class MountTestParseInvalid(AATest):
             MountRule('mount', MountRule.ALL, ('=', 'invalid'), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)  # fstype[0] should be '=' or 'in'
 
     def test_diff_fstype(self):
-        obj1 = MountRule('mount', ('=', 'ext4'), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
+        obj1 = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext4']), MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
         obj2 = MountRule('mount', MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL)
         self.assertFalse(obj1.is_equal(obj2, False))
 
@@ -129,14 +144,6 @@ class MountTestParseInvalid(AATest):
             MountRule('remount', MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL, '/foo', MountRule.ALL)
 
 
-class MountTestFilesystems(AATest):
-    def test_fs(self):
-        with open('/proc/filesystems') as f:
-            for line in f:
-                fs_name = line.split()[-1]
-                self.assertTrue(fs_name in valid_fs, '/proc/filesystems contains %s which is not listed in MountRule valid_fs' % fs_name)
-
-
 class MountTestGlob(AATest):
     def test_glob(self):
         globList = [(
@@ -199,49 +206,58 @@ class MountIsCoveredTest(AATest):
     def test_is_covered(self):
         obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*', '/b*')
         tests = [
-            ('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b', '/bar'),
-            ('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar', '/b')
+            ('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b', '/bar'),
+            ('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar', '/b')
         ]
         for test in tests:
             self.assertTrue(obj.is_covered(MountRule(*test)))
             self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule(*test)))
 
     def test_is_covered_fs_source(self):
-        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
-        self.assertTrue(obj.is_covered(MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)))
-        self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)))
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+        self.assertTrue(obj.is_covered(MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext3']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)))
+        self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext3']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)))
 
-    def test_is_covered_regex(self):
-        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ('sys*', 'fuse.*')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+    def test_is_covered_aare_1(self):
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['sys*', 'fuse.*']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
         tests = [
-            ('mount', ('=', ('sysfs', 'fuse.s3fs')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL),
-            ('mount', ('=', ('sysfs', 'fuse.jmtpfs', 'fuse.s3fs', 'fuse.obexfs', 'fuse.obexautofs', 'fuse.fuseiso')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+            ('mount', ('=', ['sysfs', 'fuse.s3fs']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL),
+            ('mount', ('=', ['sysfs', 'fuse.jmtpfs', 'fuse.s3fs', 'fuse.obexfs', 'fuse.obexautofs', 'fuse.fuseiso']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+        ]
+        for test in tests:
+            self.assertTrue(obj.is_covered(MountRule(*test)))
+            self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule(*test)))
+    def test_is_covered_aare_2(self):
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext{3,4}', '{cgroup*,fuse.*}']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+        tests = [
+            ('mount', ('=', ['ext3']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL),
+            ('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4', 'cgroup', 'cgroup2', 'fuse.jmtpfs', 'fuse.s3fs', 'fuse.obexfs', 'fuse.obexautofs', 'fuse.fuseiso']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
         ]
         for test in tests:
             self.assertTrue(obj.is_covered(MountRule(*test)))
             self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule(*test)))
 
     def test_is_notcovered(self):
-        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*', '/b*')
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*', '/b*')
         tests = [
-            ('mount',   ('in', ('ext3', 'ext4')),   ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('procfs', 'ext4')),  ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('ext3')),            ('=', ('rw')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),    MountRule.ALL, '/foo/b*',      '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('in', ['ext3', 'ext4']),   ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['procfs', 'ext4']),  ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['ext3']),            ('=', ('rw')), '/foo/bar',     '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),    MountRule.ALL, '/foo/b*',      '/bar'    ),
             ('mount',   MountRule.ALL,              ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*',      '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),    ('=', ('ro')), '/invalid/bar', '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),    ('=', ('ro')), '/invalid/bar', '/bar'    ),
             ('umount',  MountRule.ALL,              MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL,  '/bar'    ),
             ('remount', MountRule.ALL,              MountRule.ALL, MountRule.ALL,  '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),    ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs',        '/bar'    ),
-            ('mount',   ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')),    ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*',      '/invalid'),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),    ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs',        '/bar'    ),
+            ('mount',   ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']),    ('=', ('ro')), '/foo/b*',      '/invalid'),
         ]
         for test in tests:
             self.assertFalse(obj.is_covered(MountRule(*test)))
             self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule(*test)))
 
     def test_is_not_covered_fs_source(self):
-        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
-        test = ('mount', ('=', ('ext3', 'ext4')), ('=', ('ro')), 'procfs', MountRule.ALL)
+        obj = MountRule('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), 'tmpfs', MountRule.ALL)
+        test = ('mount', ('=', ['ext3', 'ext4']), ('=', ('ro')), 'procfs', MountRule.ALL)
         self.assertFalse(obj.is_covered(MountRule(*test)))
         self.assertFalse(obj.is_equal(MountRule(*test)))
 
diff --git a/utils/test/test-parser-simple-tests.py b/utils/test/test-parser-simple-tests.py
index 40f61ef85..451af7d22 100644
--- a/utils/test/test-parser-simple-tests.py
+++ b/utils/test/test-parser-simple-tests.py
@@ -324,9 +324,6 @@ unknown_line = (
     'bare_include_tests/ok_85.sd',
     'bare_include_tests/ok_86.sd',
 
-    # mount with fstype using AARE
-    'mount/ok_12.sd',
-
     # Mount with flags in {remount, [r]unbindable, [r]shared, [r]private, [r]slave} does not support a source
     'mount/ok_opt_68.sd',
     'mount/ok_opt_69.sd',

Places

File utils-relax-mount-rules.diff of Package apparmor (Revision c810bd9816fe6c535130090b0e7835b2)

Places